This article is part of the ISC’s Transform21 series, which features resources from our network of scientists and change-makers to help inform the urgent transformations needed to achieve climate and biodiversity goals.
By Matthew Hoffmann, University of Toronto. This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
Well, this is beginning to feel old: 2021 was another year of climate catastrophes — just like the one before it.
Yet another year of fires and floods, with more beckoning for 2022. And, like last year, there are desperate calls for 2022 to be a year of accelerated climate action. It has to be, in so many ways (technological, social, economic, political), if we are to avoid the worst effects of climate change.
Yet one thing that’s different in 2022 than years past is that we we now have a completed, functioning global climate treaty. At the November 2021 COP26 meeting in Glasgow, the international community finalized the remaining details of the Paris Agreement.
Much of the world, or at least the media in North America and the United Kingdom, met this news with confusion. CNN, the Economist, the Globe and Mail and even CBC Kids ran stories asking the same question: “Was COP26 a Success?”
The consensus that emerged in the media and among columnists was that some progress was made even if it didn’t fix climate change. Environmental activists were more certain: COP26 was a failure.
Both reactions are reasonable because two facts about climate action uncomfortably coexist.
- The Paris Agreement is working as it was designed, doing what it is supposed to do and what it can do as an international agreement.
- The Paris Agreement agreement alone can’t save us. The global response to climate change is not generating transformation at the pace or scale we need to avoid the worst impacts of climate change.
Paris is a means, not an end
The Paris Agreement is a context for climate action, not action itself. Its main substance is a collectively agreed goal (keep warming to 1.5 C) and it mandates that countries develop their own climate plans, which they have mostly done and some have even ratcheted them up since 2015.
It also provides infrastructure for collective reporting and monitoring of plans with common metrics, for taking stock of how states’ commitments translate to the overarching goal, for developing a global carbon market and mobilizing finance for the Global South. After Glasgow, most of this is now in place.
Yay! The Paris Agreement is working … and yet the climate is still burning.
Unfortunately, the Paris Agreement can work perfectly and states’ individual efforts can still come up short. The Paris Agreement is a means, not an end.
Turning this global institutional context into an effective global response to climate change requires ambitious national action. The Paris Agreement will succeed in the broader sense if states ramp up the ambition and implementation of their climate plans. That’s the whole ballgame. Fortunately, the Paris Agreement infrastructure and approach provide some mechanisms to encourage this.
The co-operative infrastructure — especially transparency and common reporting timelines and metrics for greenhouse gas emissions and national climate actions — may help catalyze virtuous cycles of increasing ambition. Even though the Paris Agreement relies on individual instead of joint commitments, countries are still wary about moving ahead of their peers and competitors. Having transparent national commitments with standardized reporting is potentially a way to alleviate those concerns.
Efforts to mobilize finance need to be drastically improved, however. This was a major sticking point at COP26 that almost derailed the conference.
States in the Global North are seriously underperforming on their pledged commitments on climate and adaptation finance. They have come up at least US$20 billion short on a US$100 billion per year pledge — an amount itself considered “miniscule” compared to what’s ultimately necessary. Mobilizing finance for the Global South was a key bargain that made the Paris Agreement itself possible and its future success depends on this commitment being fulfilled.
Accountability and inclusion can instigate change
These mechanisms, however, rely on countries wanting to act with enthusiasm and equity. That’s the necessary change and it’s what climate activists took to the streets around the world to demand. The logic of accountability and inclusion built into the Paris Agreement offers opportunities to instigate change.
First, accountability in the Paris Agreement is largely external — the agreement itself doesn’t have enforcement mechanisms because decisions and actions are taken domestically. This provides citizens and activists with concrete targets — national climate plans.
We need more national legislation like Canada’s Net Zero Accountability Act. We need citizen pressure to continue ratcheting up national ambition and implementation to ensure that such legislation isn’t greenwashing.
Second, the Paris Agreement recognizes the importance of mobilizing the full range of corporations, cities, provinces, NGOs, communities and so on to meet the 1.5 C target. The work done by these non-state and sub-state players can change what countries see as possible and appropriate climate action.
So, we have Paris and that’s a good thing, somewhat. It is working. It provides the infrastructure to do more; to do better. It’s not magic though. As Catherine Abreu, the executive director of the Climate Action Network, observed:
“The final outcomes of COP26 gives Canadians a clear image of where the world is at: united in the desperate hope to limit warming to 1.5 C and avoid the most irreversible impacts of climate change; divided on the scale of effort required to achieve that goal.”
The animating force for the Paris Agreement to truly succeed is the efforts that people, communities, NGOs and corporations deploy to make states see the necessity of the proper scale of effort. We have Paris, but hope for 2022 will be found in the movements and politics that are growing across the globe; in fighting for pandemic recovery plans that focus on justice, equity and sustainability; in the everyday actions of concerned individuals that build social momentum for change.
Matthew Hoffmann, Professor of Political Science and Co-Director Environmental Governance Lab, University of Toronto. This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
Image by Russ Allison Loar via Flickr.
President of the International Science Council, Sir Peter Gluckman, addresses EU Ministers
World Climate Research Programme launches a Lighthouse Activity on Climate Intervention Research
Achieving sustainable development requires the full inclusion of women and girls in science
Fostering tomorrow’s science: the ISC's engagements with Early and Mid-Career Researchers in 2023
"What's holding us back?": how economists and social scientists might hold the key to climate action
Podcast with Cory Doctorow: Science Fiction and the Future of Science: Leveraging Digital Advancements for the Future
For science-based decision-making on the climate emergency: 10 new insights in climate science
Podcast with Qiufan Chen: Science Fiction and the Future of Science: Values and Senses in Artificial Intelligence
Podcast with Fernanda Trías: Science Fiction and the Future of Science: Lessons from an Eco-Dystopia
Podcast with Vandana Singh: Science Fiction and the Future of Science: Data, Narrative, and Transdisciplinarity
Policy Brief: Global Sea-Level Rise
The costs of shifting scenarios: Why the IPCC should maintain consistent vocabulary in climate assessments
New ISC policy brief: A call for a formal scientific voice in the global fight against plastic pollution
Converging and interdependent crises are amplifying the impacts of one another with often devastating consequences
FAO and the International Science Council join forces to strengthen science-policy interfaces for agrifood systems
Podcast with Karen Lord: Science Fiction and the Future of Science: Long-Term Thinking in Policy-making
Reframing Trust in Science for Multilateral Policy: Insights from the Science Journalists Forum
Policy Brief: Creating a Strong Interface between Science, Policy and Society to Tackle Global Plastic Pollution
One Planet Polar Summit, scientists striving to bridge the science-policy gap for urgent action: "every tenth of a degree Celsius matters"
Science Fiction and the Future of Science
Call for nomination of experts to draft an outline of the IPCC Special Report on Climate Change and Cities - deadline 15 November
A framework for evaluating rapidly developing digital and related technologies: AI, large language models and beyond
Cultivating a proactive approach to crises: first meeting of the UNEP/ISC foresight expert panel
"The making of the Golden Record of our century": daring to pursue mission-oriented science
To achieve sustainable development, the world needs to mobilize around a big science approach once more
Global science needs a new approach to tackle climate change and complex sustainability question
The ISC addresses the UN High Level Political Forum and meets with the UN Secretary General
A Model for Implementing Mission Science for Sustainability: proposed by the Technical Advisory Group to the Global Commission on Science Missions for Sustainability
Frontiers Planet Prize, second edition: celebrating the world’s most innovative sustainability scientists by 1 November
Protecting the ocean: 5 essential reads on invasive species, overfishing and other threats to sea life
Rising to the challenge of the High-Level Meeting on the Sendai Framework: Insights from the ISC's latest disaster risk reduction report
Nurturing a Sustainable Future: Collaboration, Empowerment, Trust, and Resilience in Science at the ISC Mid-term Members Meeting
ISC's nomination track ensures transdisciplinary and global representation in UNEP's Scientific Advisory Group for GEO-7 Assessment
UN 2023 Water Conference carries new engagements towards realizing SDG6 and future avenues for a decade of action
IPCC report: the world must cut emissions and urgently adapt to the new climate realities
Second conference on the war in Ukraine: exploring the impact on the science sector and supporting initiatives
ISC-BBC StoryWorks partnership ends on a high note, delivering some of the highest engagement for the BBC
Science policy advice in times of crisis
World is set to miss UN targets for preventing deadly and costly disasters by 2030, warns International Science Council
Contribute a blog or news item to the ISC
The ISC and UNEP to cooperate on advancing the use of science in environmental policy and decision-making
Science in Times of Crisis Episode 3 - The Fallout of Conflict: The Arctic and Outer Space
There are 8 years left to meet the UN Sustainable Development Goals, but is it enough time?
Special interview series on COP 27- Interview with Nick Perkins about climate change and science communication
Are we in a new era of climate adaptation implementation? The role of regional governments in facilitating local action
In the face of extreme weather events, coordinated global action to address climate change is needed at COP27
Professor Carlos Lopes on why Africa needs to stick to renewables despite the temptation of gas
Poverty - or the death of Zaw Lin Oo
Stories of transformations to sustainability
Happy birthday to the Montreal Protocol – the most successful environmental treaty of all time?
Position paper of the Scientific and Technological Community Major Group for the 2022 High-level Political Forum
International Science Council appoints 66 Foundation Fellows who have made exceptional contributions to the role of science as a global public good
Cycling towards sustainable development
A letter to our fellow citizens of Earth
The Biggest Carbon Sink of All
Managed retreat from areas threatened by floods can catalyse positive social transformations
The climate crisis is a health crisis
Funding Science for Global Sustainability
Women Leading on Equitable and Inclusive Solutions to address the Climate Emergency: Webinar
The window for climate action to avoid dangerous systemic risks is narrowing, warns latest IPCC report
An early career perspective on the science-policy interface in the decade of climate action following COP26
Holiday binge-watching: Science edition
Our most popular stories from 2021
Staying below 1.5°C: what are the chances?
If universities want to hit climate targets, they should use their land for carbon offsetting
Major scientific assessment of the Amazon region issues urgent call to end deforestation and avert tipping points
Climate change projections for Pakistan: the need for sustainable solutions to protect its people and biodiversity
Four considerations for accelerating progress on climate change at the science-policy interface
Ten New Insights in Climate Science 2021 report highlights critical research and policy implications for addressing the climate crisis
Ahead of COP26, Ekanem I. Braide shares her perspective on the priorities for action and the role of science
Climate risk assessment gaps: seamless integration of weather and climate information for community resilience
Increasing the participation of women in the climate change debate, including as leaders, is essential for a carbon-zero future
Deepening interactions between science and policy on the way to COP26: What role for science publishers?
Science as a Global Public Good
Predicting the climate of the next decade
Call for emergency action to limit global temperature increases, restore biodiversity, and protect health
Coastal communities in the Arctic rely on structural measures to adapt to climate change, but should they?
Solar Geoengineering at a Standstill?
Indigenous inclusion in the science-policy sphere requires more than symbolic gestures: Interview with Meg Parsons
Deep and sustained emissions reductions required to head off rapid climate change affecting all regions of the world
The carbon skyscraper
Tell me a story – why climate change communication needs to embrace our childlike curiosity
We're in the midst of a global wake-up call
Position paper for 2021 HLPF
COP26 Climate Action Champion Nigel Topping on creating an 'ambition loop' for bolder pathways to change
2021 Forum on Science, Technology and Innovation for the SDGs: amplifying STI for a sustainable and resilient COVID-19 recovery
COVID-19 has sparked new relationships between academia and policymakers – we must maintain them
Strengthening the links between science and society for action on climate change in France
Target high-carbon emitters to accelerate green transition, say leading experts on behavioural change
World Engineering Day - science and engineering are key partners in building a sustainable future
Working together: Future Earth and WCRP announce partnership to jointly address major societal challenges
What are the climate breakthroughs in 2020?
The “How” of transformation
Taking stock of progress on global change: What to expect from the UNEP Global Assessments Synthesis Report
Call for nominations: ISC Awards Programme
Tackling Climate Change with COVID-19 Urgency - by ISC Patron, Mary Robinson and ISC President, Daya Reddy
COP25: Time for action
Call for nominations of experts to serve on the Editorial Board of the IPCC Emission Factor Database
Official Statement by the Scientific and Technological Community (STC) Major Group Global Platform for Disaster Risk Reduction 2019, Geneva, Switzerland
Science and Policy Forum underscores need for collaboration across science, policy makers and society for success in disaster risk reduction
ISC launches policy briefs ahead of the UN Global Platform on Disaster Risk Reduction (GP2019)
The political challenge of achieving transformations to 1.5ºC – the role of social justice
COP24 side event on The CitiesIPCC Research and Action Agenda for effective urban responses to climate change
Transforming southern African cities in a changing climate – Q and A with Alice McClure from the University of Cape Town
Public launch event of the Council explores values of science and links between science, politics and society
Highlights of 2017
Future of Science: Voices from our partners
Future of Science: Voices from our partners
Future of science: Voices from our partners
Future of science: Voices from our partners
International Council for Science calls on United States to support international efforts to combat dangerous climate change
New report from scientific experts provides a unique guide to translate Sustainable Development Goals into reality
ICSU at the U.N. Ocean Conference
World Climate Research Programme (WCRP)
What we do
ICSU Unions receive award to launch multi-year initiatives in science outreach and education
International experts submit report on Future of the Seas and Oceans to G7 Science and Technology Ministers meeting in Japan
Former ICSU President Jane Lubchenco awarded Tyler Prize for Environmental Achievement for Work in Changing Policy
More than 1,000 delegates gather in Geneva for talks on global disaster risk reduction agreement
Future Earth 2025 Vision
Future Earth Strategic Research Agenda 2014
UN supports call for an international science advisory mechanism on disaster risk reduction
ICSU President gives statement at Rio+20
Intergovernmental Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES) to meet in Panama
ICSU Foresight Analysis peer-reviewed
Polar year comes to a close
Ecosystem Change and Human Wellbeing
ICSU launches new programme to understand the human impact on Earth’s life-support systems
International Council for Science (ICSU) launches major research programme on natural disasters
IPY Polar Day Focusing on People
IPY Polar Land and Life Day
IPY Day Focusing on Changing Earth
IPY Day Focusing on Ice Sheets
IPY presents Sea Ice Day
ICSU and Climate Science (2006)
At Pivotal Event in China, the International Council for Science Releases New Strategy to Strengthen International Science for the Benefit of Society
ICSU Pursues New Initiative that Challenges Science to Do More to Prevent Natural Disasters