This article first published by the Earth Commission on 9 September 2022
An international research team synthesized evidence for tipping points, their temperature thresholds, timescales, and impacts from a comprehensive review of over 200 papers published since 2008, when climate Tipping points were first rigorously defined. They have increased the list of potential tipping points from nine to sixteen.
The research, published in advance of a major conference “Tipping Points: from climate crisis to positive transformation” at the University of Exeter (12-14 September), concludes human emissions have already pushed Earth into the tipping points danger zone.
Five of the sixteen may be triggered at today’s temperatures: the Greenland and West Antarctic ice sheets, widespread abrupt permafrost thaw, collapse of convection in the Labrador Sea, and massive die-off of tropical coral reefs. Four of these move from possible events to likely at 1.5°C global warming, with five more becoming possible around this level of heating.
Summary Map by Earth Commission/Globaïa: The location of climate tipping elements in the cryosphere (blue), biosphere (green) and ocean/atmosphere (orange), and global warming levels their tipping points will likely be triggered at. Pins are colored according to our central global warming threshold estimate being below 2°C, i.e. within the Paris Agreement range (red, circles); between 2 and 4°C, i.e. accessible with current policies (pink, diamonds); and 4°C and above (purple, triangles).
Lead author David Armstrong McKay from Stockholm Resilience Centre, University of Exeter, and the Earth Commission says,
We can see signs of destabilization already in parts of the West Antarctic and Greenland ice sheets, in permafrost regions, the Amazon rainforest, and potentially the Atlantic overturning circulation as well.
The world is already at risk of some tipping points. As global temperatures rise further, more tipping points become possible. The chance of crossing tipping points can be reduced by rapidly cutting greenhouse gas emissions, starting immediately.David Armstrong McKay
The Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), stated that risks of triggering climate tipping points become high by around 2°C above preindustrial temperatures and very high by 2.5-4°C.
This new analysis indicates that Earth may have already left a ‘safe’ climate state when temperatures exceeded approximately 1°C warming. A conclusion of the research is therefore that even the United Nations’ Paris Agreement goal to limit warming to well-below 2°C and preferably 1.5°C is not enough to fully avoid dangerous climate change. According to the assessment, tipping point likelihood increases markedly in the ‘Paris range’ of 1.5-2°C warming, with even higher risks beyond 2°C.
The study provides strong scientific support for the Paris Agreement and associated efforts to limit global warming to 1.5°C, because it shows that the risk of tipping points escalates beyond this level. To have a 50% chance of achieving 1.5°C and thus limiting tipping point risks, global greenhouse gas emissions must be cut by half by 2030, reaching net-zero by 2050.
Co-author Johan Rockström, co-chair of the Earth Commission and director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research says,
The world is heading towards 2-3°C of global warming. This sets Earth on course to cross multiple dangerous tipping points that will be disastrous for people across the world. To maintain liveable conditions on Earth, protect people from rising extremes, and enable stable societies, we must do everything possible to prevent crossing tipping points. Every tenth of a degree counts.Johan Rockström
The researchers categorized the tipping elements into nine systems that affect the entire Earth system, such as Antarctica and the Amazon rainforest, and a further seven systems that if tipped would have profound regional consequences. The latter include the West African monsoon and the death of most coral reefs around the equator. Several new tipping elements such as Labrador Sea convection and East Antarctic subglacial basins have been added compared to the 2008 assessment, while Arctic summer sea ice and the El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) have been removed for lack of evidence of tipping dynamics.
Co-author Ricarda Winkelmann, a researcher at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research and a member of the Earth Commission says,
Importantly, many tipping elements in the Earth system are interlinked, making cascading tipping points a serious additional concern. In fact, interactions can lower the critical temperature thresholds beyond which individual tipping elements begin destabilizing in the long-run.Ricarda Winkelmann
Armstrong McKay says, “We have made a first step towards updating the world on tipping point risks. There is an urgent need for a deeper international analysis, especially on tipping element interactions, towards which the Earth Commission is starting a Tipping Points Model Intercomparison Project (“TIPMIP”).”
Access the full article in Science here.
The research will be discussed at a major conference, “Tipping Points: from climate crisis to positive transformation” at the University of Exeter 12-14 September.
The Earth Commission is an international team of leading natural and social scientists and five working groups of additional experts. The Commission is led by three distinguished professors: Johan Rockström, Joyeeta Gupta and Dahe Qin.
Future Earth is a major international research platform providing the knowledge and support to accelerate transformations to a sustainable world. Future Earth is an affiliated body of the ISC.
Image by elycefeliz on Flickr
Cultivating a proactive approach to crises: first meeting of the UNEP/ISC foresight expert panel
"The making of the Golden Record of our century": daring to pursue mission-oriented science
To achieve sustainable development, the world needs to mobilize around a big science approach once more
Proclamation of the International Decade of Sciences for Sustainable Development by the United Nations General Assembly
Sustainability in the Digital Age
Global science needs a new approach to tackle climate change and complex sustainability question
Ambitious global $1 billion per year ‘mission science’ model needed to win on sustainable development in time, warn experts
Charting a New Course: Science Day to Pioneer Evidence-Based Strategies for SDG Acceleration at the HLPF 2023
A Model for Implementing Mission Science for Sustainability: proposed by the Technical Advisory Group to the Global Commission on Science Missions for Sustainability
Frontiers Planet Prize, second edition: celebrating the world’s most innovative sustainability scientists
Protecting the ocean: 5 essential reads on invasive species, overfishing and other threats to sea life
The ISC at the Second Session of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Committee on Plastic Pollution
Nurturing a Sustainable Future: Collaboration, Empowerment, Trust, and Resilience in Science at the ISC Mid-term Members Meeting
From Antarctica to Space: updates from Affiliated Bodies on Day 3 of ISC Mid-term meeting
ISC's nomination track ensures transdisciplinary and global representation in UNEP's Scientific Advisory Group for GEO-7 Assessment
Rebalancing Waste Management Governance in Cities with Informal Systems: Engaging Local Stakeholders and Academics through Transdisciplinary Research
Launch of the LIRA 2030 Africa reports highlighting key achievements and lessons learned from advancing transdisciplinary science in Africa
LIRA 2030 Africa: Learning from Practising Transdisciplinary Research for Sustainable Development in African Cities
UN 2023 Water Conference carries new engagements towards realizing SDG6 and future avenues for a decade of action
IPCC report: the world must cut emissions and urgently adapt to the new climate realities
Delivering actionable and science-based water solutions: new ISC policy brief launched ahead of the 2023 UN Water Conference
ISC-BBC StoryWorks partnership ends on a high note, delivering some of the highest engagement for the BBC
Towards a New Urban Health Science
Call to engage in Voluntary National Reviews
Distinguished lecture series - From fire to space - Basic sciences lead and shape our paths toward sustainable development
In wake of ‘natural’ disasters, not reducing biodiversity loss is a big missed opportunity
Contribute a blog or news item to the ISC
International Science Council deplores the exclusion of women from university education in Afghanistan and urges the Afghan authorities to reverse their decision
The ISC and UNEP to cooperate on advancing the use of science in environmental policy and decision-making
Science in Times of Crisis Episode 3 - The Fallout of Conflict: The Arctic and Outer Space
There are 8 years left to meet the UN Sustainable Development Goals, but is it enough time?
Special interview series on COP 27- Interview with Nick Perkins about climate change and science communication
Are we in a new era of climate adaptation implementation? The role of regional governments in facilitating local action
In the face of extreme weather events, coordinated global action to address climate change is needed at COP27
Professor Carlos Lopes on why Africa needs to stick to renewables despite the temptation of gas
Call for nominations of experts - IPCC Workshop on the Use of Scenarios in AR6 and Subsequent Assessments
Stories of transformations to sustainability
Happy birthday to the Montreal Protocol – the most successful environmental treaty of all time?
Funding for resilience: Five key objectives to protect vulnerable groups through Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Investing
Cycling towards sustainable development
A letter to our fellow citizens of Earth
The Biggest Carbon Sink of All
Three things to know about how Intellectual Property can contribute to sustainability transitions
Managed retreat from areas threatened by floods can catalyse positive social transformations
The climate crisis is a health crisis
New Technical Advisory Group to support the Global Commission on Science Missions for Sustainability
Global Forum of Funders
Funding Science for Global Sustainability
World Water Day - March 22
Systemic Risk Briefing Note highlights complexity of interconnected, interdependent, and uncertain challenges
Women Leading on Equitable and Inclusive Solutions to address the Climate Emergency: Webinar
The window for climate action to avoid dangerous systemic risks is narrowing, warns latest IPCC report
Celebrating World Pulses Day 2022
An early career perspective on the science-policy interface in the decade of climate action following COP26
Holiday binge-watching: Science edition
Our most popular stories from 2021
Staying below 1.5°C: what are the chances?
The International Year of Basic Sciences for Sustainable Development proclaimed by the United Nations General Assembly for 2022
If universities want to hit climate targets, they should use their land for carbon offsetting
Major scientific assessment of the Amazon region issues urgent call to end deforestation and avert tipping points
Climate change projections for Pakistan: the need for sustainable solutions to protect its people and biodiversity
Four considerations for accelerating progress on climate change at the science-policy interface
Ten New Insights in Climate Science 2021 report highlights critical research and policy implications for addressing the climate crisis
Ahead of COP26, Ekanem I. Braide shares her perspective on the priorities for action and the role of science
Climate risk assessment gaps: seamless integration of weather and climate information for community resilience
Increasing the participation of women in the climate change debate, including as leaders, is essential for a carbon-zero future
Deepening interactions between science and policy on the way to COP26: What role for science publishers?
Science as a Global Public Good
Predicting the climate of the next decade
Strengthening the resilience of our global food system while advancing its transformation
Call for emergency action to limit global temperature increases, restore biodiversity, and protect health
Coastal communities in the Arctic rely on structural measures to adapt to climate change, but should they?
Solar Geoengineering at a Standstill?
Deep and sustained emissions reductions required to head off rapid climate change affecting all regions of the world
The carbon skyscraper
Navigating towards sustainability: how research networks can make a difference using the ‘network compass’
Tell me a story – why climate change communication needs to embrace our childlike curiosity
We're in the midst of a global wake-up call
Critical social science perspectives on transformations to sustainability – emerging framings and approaches
COP26 Climate Action Champion Nigel Topping on creating an 'ambition loop' for bolder pathways to change
Strengthening the links between science and society for action on climate change in France
Target high-carbon emitters to accelerate green transition, say leading experts on behavioural change
Working scientist podcast: Democratizing knowledge and access to tools for sustainable development
Working together: Future Earth and WCRP announce partnership to jointly address major societal challenges
What are the climate breakthroughs in 2020?
The Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission launches the Global Ocean Science Report 2020
The “How” of transformation
Taking stock of progress on global change: What to expect from the UNEP Global Assessments Synthesis Report
Kyoto Landslide Commitment launched to increase understanding on how to reduce landslide risk
ISC and Sustainability in the Digital Age partner to drive transformative system changes for an equitable world
Global Young Academy promote sustainable solutions to problems within global health and higher education
Transformation to Sustainability: Integrating Indigenous and Western knowledge systems for water management and governance
Call for nominations: ISC Awards Programme
Coalition for Environmental Sustainability in support of the UN’s Roadmap for Digital Cooperation
SDG interactions as a national policy driver
Tackling Climate Change with COVID-19 Urgency - by ISC Patron, Mary Robinson and ISC President, Daya Reddy
COP25: Time for action
Call for nominations of experts to serve on the Editorial Board of the IPCC Emission Factor Database
Why we need a UN charter
Our Common Digital Future
Funding Science for Sustainability
The triumphs and trials of transdisciplinary research: reflections on the un-disciplining of disciplines
The political challenge of achieving transformations to 1.5ºC – the role of social justice
COP24 side event on The CitiesIPCC Research and Action Agenda for effective urban responses to climate change
How to bring clean energy to informal settlements: Co-designing sustainable energy solutions in Kenya, Uganda and South Africa
Transforming southern African cities in a changing climate – Q and A with Alice McClure from the University of Cape Town
Future of Science: Voices from our partners
Future of Science: Voices from our partners
Future of science: Voices from our partners
Future of science: Voices from our partners
SDG Interactions, gender, science-policy interface: ICSU at the High Level Political Forum
First UN Oceans conference highlights urgency to address marine pollution, warming and over-fishing
International Council for Science calls on United States to support international efforts to combat dangerous climate change
New report from scientific experts provides a unique guide to translate Sustainable Development Goals into reality
ICSU at the U.N. Ocean Conference
Sustainable Development Goals
World Climate Research Programme (WCRP)
Call for pre-proposals: Advancing the implementation of Sustainable Development Goal 11 on cities in Africa
Call for Nominations for the Scientific Committee for the Urban Health and Wellbeing programme
ICSU Unions receive award to launch multi-year initiatives in science outreach and education
GSDR report launches in France – High level event and workshop co-organized by ICSU, UNDESA, IDDRI and IRD
Global Sustainable Development Goals need clearer, more measurable targets, according to new report from science experts
2015 is the International Year of Light
Landmark scientifc data conference ends with strong support of data sharing for sustainability
Future Earth 2025 Vision
Future Earth Strategic Research Agenda 2014
Nature publishes paper on SDGs by team of authors from ICSU, IGBP and other organisations
Paper published on ICSU's programme on Health and Wellbeing in the Changing Urban Environment
Polar year comes to a close
Science Plan on Sustainable Energy – ICSU Regional Office for Latin America and the Caribbean
ICSU launches new programme to understand the human impact on Earth’s life-support systems
International Council for Science (ICSU) launches major research programme on natural disasters
IPY Polar Day Focusing on People
IPY Polar Land and Life Day
IPY Day Focusing on Changing Earth
IPY Day Focusing on Ice Sheets
IPY presents Sea Ice Day
ICSU and Climate Science (2006)
ICSU and Sustainable Development (2006)
At Pivotal Event in China, the International Council for Science Releases New Strategy to Strengthen International Science for the Benefit of Society
ICSU Pursues New Initiative that Challenges Science to Do More to Prevent Natural Disasters
ICSU Scientific meetings probe global issues