The ongoing pandemic has resulted – among many other momentous consequences for science in particular and society in general – in an unprecedented engagement of the general interested public with the scientific process. An important part of this public discourse are questions about science such as:
- At which stage of the scientific process can we rely on a discovery? Are preprints a good source of scientific knowledge? If not, which role does the peer review process play in transforming them into a good source?
- What does it mean when two different scientific measures (say, the 7-day incidence rate and the hospitalization rate) give divergent accounts of the current situation? Can only one of them reflect the truth about the current situation?
- In what form does and should science enter the process of making policy decisions? If there is a conflict between the interests of different players in the system, how do we make sure that our decisions are wise and take all aspects into account?
The non-academic and public discussion of these and similar questions concerning the scientific developments on the COVID-19 pandemic has been encapsulated in the phrase “We have all become (hobby) epidemiologists”. The fact that many of the questions are very difficult and do not have simple answers has been abused by malicious actors to cast doubt on the scientific process and manipulate the public discussion. A careful inspection of the above questions shows, however, that they are not epidemiological questions, but rather questions about the scientific method, its role in society, and its limitations, i.e., Philosophy of Science. So we should like to correct the above phrase to “We have all become (hobby) philosophers of science”.
The dangers of manipulation of the public discussion towards science scepticism are rooted in a great lack of understanding of very basic philosophical issues about science. Surely, the public debate has also unearthed a great lack of understanding of basic statistics and of basic science, and it is quite natural to call for more education in these fields; but we should like to use this year’s UNESCO World Philosophy Day (18 November 2021) to focus on the deficiency in the understanding of fundamental philosophical ideas. The world needs more basic understanding of how the scientific process works, what scientific results mean, and how they can be used in decision processes, in short, a basic understanding of Philosophy of Science.
Both at the secondary and tertiary levels of education, philosophical issues of science should have a central place: this was demanded by the Helsinki Manifesto of the Division for Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science and Technology of ISC Member, the International Union of History and Philosophy of Science and Technology (DLMPST/IUHPST) in August 2015.
In addition, philosophers of science should play an active role in policy debates that involve scientific decision making. As scientists, we can use the UNESCO World Philosophy Day to reflect on what role we can play to achieve these goals.
Photo by Alexas_Fotos on Unsplash
Related Items
Pacific Islands Academy of Sciences and Humanities: A Pivotal Step Towards a Resilient Future
01.03.2024
President of the International Science Council, Sir Peter Gluckman, addresses EU Ministers
15.02.2024
The International Science Council appoints 100 new Fellows to help advance its vision of science as a global public good
19.12.2023
Global Science Leaders ISC and IAP Issue Joint Statement on Protecting the Autonomy of National Academies of Science
15.12.2023
For science-based decision-making on the climate emergency: 10 new insights in climate science
05.12.2023
Scientific communication: Join the Ethnografilm festival for a filmmaking experience in Paris
22.11.2023
Podcast with Karen Lord: Science Fiction and the Future of Science: Long-Term Thinking in Policy-making
13.11.2023
Request for nominations: The social determinants of mental wellbeing in young people - deadline 17 November
10.10.2023
Call for nominations: The ISC is seeking Members for the Advisory Council of the Regional Focal Point for Asia and the Pacific
24.07.2023
Nurturing a Sustainable Future: Collaboration, Empowerment, Trust, and Resilience in Science at the ISC Mid-term Members Meeting
16.05.2023
From Antarctica to Space: updates from Affiliated Bodies on Day 3 of ISC Mid-term meeting
15.05.2023
ISC Regional Focal Point for Latin America and the Caribbean gathers its Liaison Committee for the first in-person meeting
01.04.2023
ISC-BBC StoryWorks partnership ends on a high note, delivering some of the highest engagement for the BBC
13.03.2023
Achieving gender equality in Science, Technology and Engineering and Mathematics (STEM)– when will we get there?
08.03.2023
Science in Times of Crisis Episode 2 - The Current Clash: Science and the National Interest.
08.12.2022
A new ISC regional presence in the Asia-Pacific Region to be established at the Australian Academy of Science
31.10.2022
New cooperation initiatives from the ISC's Latin America and Caribbean Regional Focal Point
19.08.2022
International Youth Day: An invitation for eligible Young Academies and Associations to join the International Science Council
12.08.2022
WorldFAIR: Global cooperation on FAIR data policy and practice – Kick-Off Meeting introduces major new initiative to advance implementation of the FAIR data principles
01.07.2022
An invitation for eligible Young Academies and Associations to join the International Science Council as Affiliated Members
17.06.2022
COVID-19 likely to worsen inequalities for at least five years without renewed global cooperation, warns International Science Council
16.05.2022
An invitation for eligible Young Academies and Associations to join the International Science Council as Affiliated Members
09.05.2022
Joint letter to ISC Members from ISC President, Peter Gluckman, and Acting CEO, Mathieu Denis
06.04.2022
Call for nominations: Members for the Liaison Committee of the ISC Regional Focal Point for the Latin American and Caribbean Region
08.02.2022
Salim Abdool Karim, renowned epidemiologist and the ISC's new Vice President for Outreach and Engagement, talks "Omicron" with the Lancet
03.12.2021
Members of International Science Council commit to work for change in scientific publishing, and endorse eight principles for reform
25.10.2021
Ten outstanding individual scientists and organizations celebrated in first ever ISC Awards
13.10.2021
The global vectors of uncertainty that will influence the outcomes of the COVID-19 pandemic: results of the regional experts' discussions
14.09.2021
Reconciling radical and feasible responses to societal emergencies: learning from COVID-19
05.07.2021
A response to The Independent Panel for Pandemic Preparedness and Response’s new report on the international health response to the COVID-19 Pandemic
12.05.2021
COVID-19 has sparked new relationships between academia and policymakers – we must maintain them
20.04.2021
Introducing a new Member of the ISC: Institute for Global Environmental Strategies (IGES)
12.02.2021
Online event series for ISC Members and ISC affiliated bodies: Knowledge Sharing Sessions
16.12.2020
Statement by Phumzile Mlambo-Ngcuka, UN Women Executive Director, on the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women
25.11.2020
What are your latest findings and strategies to address the COVID-19 crisis, including for vaccine deployment?
23.11.2020
Global Young Academy promote sustainable solutions to problems within global health and higher education
28.10.2020
The future of scientific publishing under the spotlight for ISC member organizations in Europe
11.09.2020
Fighting COVID-19 in the Brazilian Amazon has exposed multiple threats and vulnerabilities – but also hope
21.08.2020
Lessons from existing disaster risk and recovery research should inform equitable and sustainable pathways out of the pandemic
13.08.2020
Small Island Developing States (SIDS) Liaison Committee appointed to strengthen links with the SIDS scientific community
15.07.2020
The World Pandemic Research Network - Addressing the societal and human impact of the COVID-19 pandemic
22.06.2020
From COVID-19 crisis comes opportunity to rethink risk - by Heide Hackmann, ISC CEO and Mami Mizutori, Secretary-General UNDRR
03.06.2020
Innovative technologies and post-Coronavirus economic recovery: A global value chains perspective
02.06.2020
Biodiversity as insurance: aligning economic stimulus packages with long-term nature conservation goals. A Corona Sustainability Compass blog by Jasper Meya
26.05.2020
Why intellectual property needs urgent attention from policy makers during the COVID-19 pandemic
20.05.2020
COVID-19 Stimulus Measures Must Save Lives, Protect Livelihoods, and Safeguard Nature to Reduce the Risk of Future Pandemics
30.04.2020
Addressing the equity, freedom and sustainability deficits to maintain social progress despite COVID-19
21.04.2020
Use the economic stimulus package to build resilient, climate-friendly economic structures
14.04.2020
Risks and opportunities in responding to the coronavirus crisis - by Prof. Dr. Dirk Messner
14.04.2020
Tackling Climate Change with COVID-19 Urgency - by ISC Patron, Mary Robinson and ISC President, Daya Reddy
01.04.2020
Four major international data organizations join forces to optimize the research data ecosystem, launching a COVID-19 appeal as their first joint action
31.03.2020
Building resilience against biological hazards and pandemics: COVID-19 and its implications for the Sendai Framework
27.03.2020
Understanding the different characteristics of African cities will be crucial in responding effectively to COVID-19 on the continent
13.03.2020