While ICSU is not privy to all the information that was available to the prosecutors, it appears that these scientists are being penalised essentially for using their experience and knowledge to provide evidence for decision-making. In the field of natural hazard risk, such scientific evidence has its limitations. The timing and strength of earthquakes cannot be accurately predicted.
Nevertheless, science can, and does, make important contributions to hazard response strategies. In the case of L’Aquila, six scientists accepted their responsibility to society to try and support decision-making in a situation of inherent uncertainty. That these scientists should be condemned to prison for so doing is a gross injustice.
The L’Aquila earthquake was a tragic event in which more than 300 people died and ICSU endorses the need to determine whether these lives might have been saved if the public authorities had reacted differently before the event. The role of scientific advice in the decision-making processes prior to the earthquake is a legitimate area of enquiry. We all need to learn the lessons from the past to be better prepared for the future. In the meantime, blaming scientists and scientific advice for the deaths that occurred in L’Aquila is a grave error that will, unfortunately, make many scientists reluctant to accept public advisory roles.
We call on the responsible authorities to take urgent and decisive steps to correct this error and ensure due justice for Franco Barberi, Enzo Boschi, Giuli Selvaggi, Gian Michele Calvi, Mauro Dolce and Claudio Eva.
[related_items ids=””]
Related Items
A guide for policy-makers: Evaluating rapidly developing technologies including AI, large language models and beyond
17.04.2024
President of the International Science Council, Sir Peter Gluckman, addresses EU Ministers
15.02.2024
The International Science Council appoints 100 new Fellows to help advance its vision of science as a global public good
19.12.2023
Global Science Leaders ISC and IAP Issue Joint Statement on Protecting the Autonomy of National Academies of Science
15.12.2023
Podcast with Qiufan Chen: Science Fiction and the Future of Science: Values and Senses in Artificial Intelligence
04.12.2023
Scientific communication: Join the Ethnografilm festival for a filmmaking experience in Paris
22.11.2023
Converging and interdependent crises are amplifying the impacts of one another with often devastating consequences
16.11.2023
Reframing Trust in Science for Multilateral Policy: Insights from the Science Journalists Forum
09.11.2023
Helping newsrooms get disaster risk ready, an International Science Council and World Editors Forum collaboration
21.08.2023
Indigenous Environmental Defenders are critical for nature and for science, but face serious risk
09.08.2023
One year of war in Ukraine: exploring the impact on the science sector and supporting initiatives
04.08.2023
Attacks on Environmental Scientists: Implications for the Free and Responsible Practice of Science
06.07.2023
Trust in Science: Episode 6 of the ISC Podcast Series on Freedom and Responsibility in Science in the 21st Century
05.06.2023
Emerging Technologies: Episode 5 of the ISC Podcast Series on Freedom and Responsibility in Science in the 21st Century
29.05.2023
The Role of the State: Episode 4 of the ISC Podcast Series on Freedom and Responsibility in Science in the 21st Century
22.05.2023
Nurturing a Sustainable Future: Collaboration, Empowerment, Trust, and Resilience in Science at the ISC Mid-term Members Meeting
16.05.2023
From Antarctica to Space: updates from Affiliated Bodies on Day 3 of ISC Mid-term meeting
15.05.2023
Science Communication: Episode 3 of the ISC Podcast Series on Freedom and Responsibility in Science in the 21st Century
15.05.2023
Scientific autonomy: Episode 2 of the ISC Podcast Series on Freedom and Responsibility in Science in the 21st Century
08.05.2023
UN International Day of Solidarity with Detained and Missing Staff Members – CFRS and SAR call for release of Niloufar Bayani
25.03.2023
Second conference on the war in Ukraine: exploring the impact on the science sector and supporting initiatives
14.03.2023
One year on: Statements, offers of assistance and resources on the current war in Ukraine
24.02.2023
Concern for science and research in Afghanistan following authorities' ban on women from higher education
24.01.2023
International Science Council deplores the exclusion of women from university education in Afghanistan and urges the Afghan authorities to reverse their decision
31.12.2022
Concern over ongoing legal proceedings against the Greek economist and statistician Andreas Georgiou
19.12.2022
Science in Times of Crisis Episode 3 - The Fallout of Conflict: The Arctic and Outer Space
15.12.2022
New report reveals professional challenges, preferences and plans of Ukrainian researchers abroad
12.12.2022
Science in Times of Crisis Episode 2 - The Current Clash: Science and the National Interest.
08.12.2022
Innovative approaches to storytelling in science celebrated at Women in Science Film Festival in Cape Town
07.12.2022
The state of HIV/AIDS research in Africa: An interview with Dr. Joyce Nyoni for World AIDS Day
01.12.2022
Special interview series on COP 27- Interview with Nick Perkins about climate change and science communication
17.11.2022
ISC and partners release report on the Ukraine Crisis, highlighting seven key recommendations for the international community to better support science systems affected by conflict
31.08.2022
Combating predatory journals and conferences through systemic change in scientific publishing
24.03.2022
A contemporary perspective on the free and responsible practice of science in the 21st century
10.12.2021
Daya Reddy highlights importance of core values of science at close of 2nd ISC General Assembly
15.10.2021
Science in Exile podcast: Alfred Babo shares his story of being an at-risk and refugee social scientist
14.10.2021
Ten outstanding individual scientists and organizations celebrated in first ever ISC Awards
13.10.2021
A new social contract must include genuine participation and partnership of Indigenous peoples in decision-making about research
09.08.2021
International Commission on the Clinical Use of Human Germline Genome Editing releases report
04.12.2020
Planned execution of disaster medicine scholar Ahmadreza Djalali must be halted immediately
01.12.2020
Join the first ‘Transformation Talks’ webinar to explore how research communication can be transformative
23.03.2020
ISC showcases academic freedom and inter- and transdisciplinary research at Sida Science Days
20.05.2019
Advisory note: Responsibilities for Preventing, Avoiding, and Mitigating Harm to Researchers Undertaking Fieldwork in Risky Settings
28.09.2017
International Council for Science issues an advisory note on the issue of gender-based harassment in the practice of science
25.11.2016
Advisory Note: Mobility and Field Research in the Sciences: Gender Equality and Prevention of Harassment
14.04.2016
CFRS supports scientists whose human rights are under threat as a result of scientific activity
10.12.2014
Call for nominations: ICSU Committee on Freedom and Responsibility in the conduct of Science
14.10.2014
Work Plan for the Committee on Freedom and Responsibility in the conduct of Science (CFRS) 2014-2017
14.10.2014
Organisation of international scientific meetings: recommendations from ICSU policy committee
11.01.2013
Global scientific community affirms its shared responsibilities for the integrity of science and its role in society
23.10.2008
Statement: Publication practices and indices and the role of peer review in research assessment
14.07.2008